The Nintendo Switch community’s longstanding desire for GameCube-style Joy-Cons has been addressed with the introduction of the Nixie Wizard and Doyoki GameCube-style controllers by Binbok. These controllers aim to capture the essence of the beloved GameCube controller, a design that has left an indelible mark on gaming history. This article takes an in-depth look at both controllers, exploring their design philosophy, ergonomics, button responsiveness, stick tension, and distinctive features, while also evaluating how well they stand up against the original GameCube controller.
Design and Comfort:
The Nixie Wizard and Doyoki controllers have emerged as GameCube-style Joy-Cons, each adopting a unique approach. Doyoki opts for a slim, sleek middle body that complements the Nintendo Switch Gamecube controller handheld mode. Conversely, Nixie leans towards a more robust design, reminiscent of the WaveBird controller. While this makes the Nixie visually appealing, it is bulkier in handheld mode compared to the Doyoki. Both controllers, however, prioritize the comfort of the hand grips, aiming for a seamless experience similar to their predecessors.
|Features||Nixie Wizard||DOYOKY Game Controller|
|Material||It Uses ABS material||It Uses ALPS joysticks which is slightly better|
|Charging Time||It takes 2.5 hours to fully charge||It also takes 2.5 Hours to fully charge|
|Battery Life||Up to 8.5 hours of continuous use on a full charge||Up to 8-10 hours of continuous use on a full charge|
|Connectivity||Wireless(Bluetooth)||Wireless, Wired(USB-C), Bluetooth|
|Weight||It weighs 248g which is higher than DOYOKY||It weighs only 162.5g|
|Joysticks||It has Removable joysticks and replaceable joysticks ring||Replaceable thumbsticks are provided in DOYOKY|
Button Feel and Stick Tension:
A shared trait of both controllers is the third-party button sensation, characterized by a slightly higher resistance than official controllers. This results in buttons with a snappy response upon rapid presses, accompanied by a subtle feeling of stickiness. The controllers’ stick tension varies; the Doyoki offers a tighter feel akin to the original GameCube controller, while the Nixie presents a looser sensation. Notably, the Nixie utilizes hall effect sensor sticks, contributing to a more stable experience and addressing concerns about stick drift.
D-pad and Shoulder Buttons:
Both controllers introduce enhanced D-pads that outsize the original GameCube design. The Nixie sports a glossy D-pad with a discernible clickiness upon input, while the Doyoki employs a matte finish, offering a softer tactile experience. Shoulder buttons are yet another arena of comparison, with the Nixie resembling mouse clicks and the Doyoki opting for the traditional softer press. Personal preference and game compatibility play a significant role in determining which approach is preferred.
Unique Features and Additional Functionalities:
Turbo buttons and remappable back buttons mark a common ground between the two controllers. Both controllers support motion controls and the ability to awaken the Switch Gamecube controller from sleep wirelessly. However, neither controller is equipped to read amiibo data. A standout feature of the Doyoki is its swappable stick heads, allowing users to personalize their controller setup. In contrast, the Nixie introduces an option to swap between octagonal and circular gates for the sticks, catering to different playstyles.
Comparison to Original GameCube Controller:
Despite their efforts to recreate the allure of the original GameCube controller, both the Nixie Wizard and Doyoki fall short of fully capturing its button response and tactile engagement. The controllers prioritize modern features and current gaming habits, resulting in deviations from the authentic experience. Nonetheless, the controllers offer additional functionalities like customizable rumble intensities and swappable parts, enhancing gameplay. Nevertheless, as third-party alternatives with prices nearing official Pro controllers, a comparative evaluation is crucial before purchase.
Concluding Gamecube Controller
The Nixie Wizard and Doyoki GameCube-style controllers offer an enticing prospect for gamers seeking a taste of nostalgia on the Nintendo Switch. While they may not flawlessly replicate the original GameCube experience, they provide a commendable compromise. The choice between the two hinges on personal inclinations, encompassing aspects such as stick tension, button feel, and additional features. These third-party contenders cater to the audience’s longing for a reminiscent experience while accommodating contemporary gaming needs on the Switch platform.